Thursday, October 30, 2008

Corporate hacking and the war on bloggers

For me, it started back in September. Just after returning to blogging post-holiday, I noticed that something wasn't quite right. I was sure I had done a post about Richard Hawley side project The Feral Cats, but it wasn't there any more. Strange, especially given that the song still appeared on my Hype Machine listing. My first thought was that I had been hacked. But by who? An outraged Richard Hawley fan, furious that I had posted a track only available on a very limited edition 10 inch single? Surely not. Slightly worried though I was, I changed my login and password and left it.

The next one to disappear was much more noticeable. A day or so after I reviewed the new TV on the Radio album, the post also disappeared, with no warning. Now something was clearly going wrong. If it was a hacker, why so discriminating? If they wanted to harm my blog, they could just have deleted the whole thing.

Things got a bit clearer when I read this post on To Die By Your Side. It seems that Coxon (who writes TDBYS) had been targeted in a similar way and his posts on The Verve and Cold War Kids had been ghosted away. So it's clearly been coming from the record companies. But hold on... I was sent the TVOTR album by the blogger-friendly 4AD (though admittedly they never give explicit permission to post). But a quick look at their website shows that TVOTR are on DGC in the US, which is part of the evil empire that is Universal. That explained a lot. Then I found out that this was happening to a lot of bloggers and it's continuing daily, even in the time that it's taken me to write this long-winded post, more bad shit has happened.

In the past, any record company complaints were usually directed via file hosts - mine would either ask me to take the offending mp3s down or delete them themselves. Earlier this year I had my account closed by one host, but I guess that's just part of this borderline game we play. There's also Web Sheriff, which although strident in tone, was similar to a record company or PR simply asking you to take something down, which is the way I prefer it. But the tactics have now switched. By going straight to Blogger and deleting the offending item is a lot more direct and painful. Plus, if you're a blogger who values writing rather than just posting mp3s, you lose something that you may have spent good time putting together.

Over the last week or so, things have taken a decidedly nastier turn. In the past eight days, I've had a further two posts deleted. This time I received an email about these, otherwise I may never have noticed. That's because one of them was from over TWO YEARS AGO. That's October 2006. The deleted post was about a FREE CD I picked up in Rough Trade, featuring a load of young folky types, none of whom are very well known, even now. However, one of them was Johnny Flynn, now signed to Vertigo, a subsidiary of our old friends Universal. The notion that they're trying to clear the internets of Flynn mp3s was confirmed on Monday when another Johnny-featuring post, this time his appearance on Jeremy Warmsley's Welcome to our TV Show, was also deleted. This is all bad stuff, not to mention pretty stupid given that the mp3s had long since been taken down. But let's think about this further for a minute:

- The live track was recorded in Jeremy Warmsley's living room and sent to me by the man himself. I'm sure it is (was?) also freely available on last.fm.

- The song on the free CD was from when Johnny Flynn was just starting out playing solo stuff and long before anyone at Universal had ever heard of him.

The latter point is compounded by fellow-blogger Ed from 17 Seconds, who had an interview with Glasvegas from January deleted last week. This was before the band had signed with major label Columbia (part of Sony BMG) and the mp3s Ed posted were with full approval of the band.

So does this mean that even if us bloggers stick to the indie and unsigned artists, and post everything with full permission, that sometime in the future some bastard is coming to come crashing down on us because in the past we've had the temerity to write about and post songs from an artist that they have gone on to sign? Does that mean that nothing is safe? Surely one of the sources of information that major labels use to find out about new bands is blogs. That's just having your cake and eating it.

But anyway, I could go on in an indignant fashion, but that would be pointless. There are a lot of bloggers out there feeling a bit vulnerable, though some have suggested some fightback action. Matthew Song, By Toad is writing to a Columbia bigwig, which should be interesting. But ultimately there's probably not much we can do against heavy handed, idiotic people who have money and legal power on their side. Actually, there are a couple of things I can to to mitigate things a bit.

1. Avoid anything on a major label. This isn't going to be very difficult, given that I don't much anyway. However the fear of future action as noted above remains.

2. Move away from Blogger. I actually tried to do this earlier in the year and move to a self-hosted Wordpress blog, but found the process horrendously complicated. However, I'm determined to do this now, because though it won't provide complete security, I'll feel a wee bit safer. Those who have this set-up (like Matthew) seem to have survived so far.

Anyway, this post is way longer than it than it has any right to be, so I'll stop now. The next few weeks in blog-land should be interesting.

Before I go, here's a song which I've been given explicit permission to post. So it should be OK. I hope.

mp3: Rod Thomas - Same Old Lines (James Yuill Remix)

39 comments:

david said...

That's a thoughtful post Growl.
And I'm with Mathew - there's a fair bit of noise being generated around the blogosphere, if it can be co-ordinated in some way we might be able get a proper response from the major labels.

Cheers for the Alton Ellis posts too - sublime.

PS Were you at Reggie Kray's funeral?

The Daily Growl said...

Well thank you.

But "PS Were you at Reggie Kray's funeral?"

is possibly the strangest question I've even been asked on here. I guess the answer is no. Was that the one in Bethnal Green about 8 years ago? Quite an event, apparently...

david said...

Sorry - it was a reference to Marina Hyde's war of words with Lily Allen in The Guardian yesterday. Apparently La Hyde received an ominous email from someone called 'The DailyGrowl', who claimed to have been at the funeral.

Nice blog though - I've just discovered it through Song By Toad.
I'll be back :D

Anonymous said...

Hey Growl, I'm a long time reader of both your blog and Song by Toad, and have been following the recent developments with great interest. I guess I picked the wrong time to start my own blog, but I'm still pretty excited by the whole "fightback" idea, and the anti-major strategy proposed by Matthew and your good self.
So, as a blogger and micro-label owner (bearfaced records, if you're interested...) I'm firmly on your side.

jayelaudio said...

Great post. I've been dealing with the same issues on my blog. I look forward to your move to Wordpress. Good luck!

Anonymous said...

I don't know that I have ever left you a comment but this post seems like a good one to chime in on. Thanks to your blog (Ive been an occasional visitor for about a year now) I have went on to purchase a lot of music. The list includes Los Campesinos, St. Vincent, Ed Harcourt, Beirut, Fleet Foxes and probably 10-20 singles.

I honestly don't remember how I came across your blog but it lead me to other music blogs from which I have bought even more music. Myspace is a great tool to discover artists but blogs like yours provide leads for the search. It's unfortunate that the record companies don't embrace the fairly cheap/free advertising... in the end it seems this behavior is lose/lose/lose. Anyway keep up the good work.

Thanks,
AJ

The Daily Growl said...

Thanks all. I'm not going to let this deter me. Just expect to see less/no major label stuff on here, but I don't suppose you read this blog for that sort of thing anyway.

David again - I'm finding the idea that I'm sending ominous messages to Marina Hyde about the Kray funeral quite amusing. Was this in reaction to her Lily PR-baiting article? There ware so many comments to that I couldn't be bothered reading them all. Is it in there? Anyway, I wonder who this 'other' daily growl is? We should meet

The Daily Growl said...

it's true

Anonymous said...

If there's a faster, easier download program, I've never seen it. I can get anything I want at lightning speeds!

Anonymous said...

фоторамки
цифровые фоторамки
купить фоторамку
купить цифровые фоторамки
transcend t photo 720
transcend t photo 810
transcend t photo 730
transcend t photo 710

Anonymous said...

It's sounds good!



--------------------------------------
酒店打工

combattery84 said...

Laptop Battery
acer Laptop Battery
apple Laptop Battery
asus Laptop Battery
compaq Laptop Battery
Dell Laptop Battery
fujitsu Laptop Battery
gateway Laptop Battery
hp Laptop Battery
ibm Laptop Battery
sony Laptop Battery
toshiba Laptop Battery
APPLE M8403 battery
APPLE A1078 Battery
APPLE A1079 battery
APPLE A1175 battery 1
APPLE a1185 battery
APPLE A1189 battery
Acer aspire 5920 battery
Acer btp-arj1 battery
Acer LC.BTP01.013 battery
Acer ASPIRE 1300 battery
Acer ASPIRE 1310 battery

skin tag removal said...

I am very happy to find this very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content. I will be back here later.

stretch mark removal cream said...

Hello.... I am very glad that I have found this blog as it contains all the informations I need.......hope you continue to developed this site for sake of us!!!!!!!!!!!!Good day!!!!!

skin tag removal said...

I believe stupid people will only do that kind of things. I hope it will be stopped in the future. I really don't like war. I want love =)

how to burn xbox 360 games said...

Well thank you.
But PS Were you at Reggie Kray’s funeral?
is possibly the strangest question I have even been asked on here. I guess the answer is no. Was that the one in Bethnal Green about 8 years ago? Quite an event, apparently.

Mikel said...

It is a very inspiring post to go through for excellent story about sustainability; food and environment in urban areas.The successful example of urban farming in Chicago can be followed in other cities to make the cities greener and less polluted. I've enjoyed reading the interesting discussion.cold sore on lips how to get rid of cold sores fast

the first years jet stroller said...

Very thought provoking post br T.D.G and i thank you for making my day..


Haily Summon
Child Councellor
The First Years jet Stroller

jersey shore season 4 said...

Great read thanks

Mikel said...

This is a very good read for me, Must concede that you are on the list of best blogger I ever discovered. Thanks for posting this great article.Remarkable post and thanks for sharing. Some stuff in here I have not considered about before.snoring solutions how to stop snoring

Melinda22 said...

I hope it should be OK. Thanks.get your ex back !venapro reviews

how to treat hemorrhoids said...

I do hope my post here won't be deleted. There are quite many spammers here but I am not one of them. I am just curious how they behave.

Latest nike shoes said...

Wonderful article ah well. Content is real attractive. The way to bring you good news: This Nike soccer cleats ultra vibrant...The Nike soccer cleats has a huge army of fans across the globe, and if you're one of them we know you love them to be bright, flashy and in-your-face colours. Checking out these New nike soccer shoes versions, part of Nike's Fall seasonal releases, we're sure you're going to love these too, they combine Laser technology and Nike Mercurial Vapor Superfly with the Vapor series!especially once they start appearing en masse on pitch. You can click "VIEW MORE" for more detailed pictures. New levels of performance after Nike Football Cleats new levels of performance after.

abanicos para boda said...

Wow, buen post, hay muchas personas buscando por eso ahora van a encontrar los recursos suficientes por su post.Thank por compartir con us.Please un puesto más al respecto ..
abanicos para boda

Abanicos Pintados said...

Veo la tranquilidad artículo crítico. Gracias por compartir de todos modos, me alegro de escuchar opiniones diferentes sobre este tema.
Abanicos Pintados

reparacion maquinas de coser said...

Si necesita más tráfico a su sitio web visite el sitio web en mi nombre. Realmente me ayudó y creo que puede ayudar a su sitio web.

Find Car Auctions said...

I've enjoyed this post. There are quite many spammers in the comments, but the article's content is good.

find doctor said...

I am shocking on this happened. But is is rare problem in blogs. I hope you will control on this in future. better luck for future.

Cast Iron Pan said...

I am very much impressive with this website and helpful info in this blog. I had search for gathered info in this website and using the nice information in this website.

John said...

This is a very good read for me, Must concede that you are on the list of best blogger I ever discovered. Thanks for posting this great article.make money online

wholesale krill oil said...

Please one more post about that. I wonder how you got so good. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect

Unknown said...

There are some very great sources here and thank you for being so kind to post them here.

sleep aid spray

sleep aid supplement

natural sleep aid

Craig Chilvers said...

I just wanted to leave a comment to say that I enjoy your blog. Looking at the number of comments, I see others feel the same way! Congratulations on a very popular blog.

Marine Loan

cheap jersey said...

Please take an article about it. I want to know if you have so good. This is really a fascinating blog, a lot of things, I can enter. One thing I want to say, your blog is so perfect

jerseys cheap said...

Si necesita más tráfico a su sitio web visite el sitio web en mi nombre. Realmente me ayudó y creo que puede ayudar a su sitio web.

Clipping Path said...

I love your blog, looks fantastic. Come back more often, of course.

Clipping Path Service said...

A real informative blog like this is an exceptionally cool helping resource for a needy information seeker like me! Thanks a lot for sharing.

Clipping Path Service said...

I really enjoyed your blog Thanks for sharing such an informative post.

David Millar said...


Thank you so much for providing such useful content. Photo Retouching Services